Friday, July 29, 2011

"Why Americans Are So Angry"

In the name of "balance", let's also look at a liberal leaning article, this one surprisingly from The Wall Street Journal. However, this just goes to show that biased and misleading writing hits both sides of the aisle. Here's the link for those of you who subscribe to wsj: Why Americans Are So Angry

This piece, by Bernie Sanders, an independent senator from Vermont, argues that Republicans want all of the deficit reduction to fall on the poor and vulnerable, in order to protect the super rich and big corporations.

In paragraph 3, Sanders states that "Republicans in Congress have been fanatically determined to protect the interests of the wealthy and large multinational corporations so that they do not contribute a single penny toward deficit reduction". As the Forbes article in my previous post points out, the wealthiest 1% of Americans pay 40% of its taxes. Unless taxes don't count towards deficit reduction, I would say that the wealthiest have paid, and will pay, substantial amounts towards deficit reduction, even at current tax rates.  What Sanders meant to say was: "Republicans in Congress have been fanatically determined to protect the interests of the wealthy and large multinational corporations so that they do not contribute even more than they already do in order to meet our new deficit reduction goals". But that doesn't have quite the same ring does it?

In paragraph 4, Sanders asserts that "If the Republicans have their way, the entire burden of deficit reduction will be placed on the elderly, the sick, children and working families." One may argue that cutting government spending might hurt the economy or weaken regulators in a way that is harmful to the country, but if that's the case, the burden is borne by all Americans, not just the elderly, sick, children, and working families.

In the third-to-last paragraph, Sanders states that in poll after poll, Americans want the wealthy to "pay their fair share of taxes", and that Americans believe those making more than 250k/year should pay even higher taxes. Did these polls ever ask what a "fair share" might be? If the polls stated that the top 1% of Americans already pay 40% of its taxes, and the bottom 50% pay nearly no taxes at all (see table 6 here), would people still think the same?

A legitimate argument can be made for increasing taxes on the wealthy to help plug the deficit, but it is not done through demagoguing about the opposing side and appealing to the nebulous principle of "fairness" for justification.

No comments:

Post a Comment